Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Questions/Suggestions
Portkey forums - Kindred Spirits > Portkey.org: A History > Official Portkey Contests > Portkey Poetry People's Choice
Mrs. Pepper
Hello... sorcerer.gif !!! Welcome to the "questions/suggestions" thread. Well, you guys know what to do. Post your queries about the contest in this thread. ricelius and I will answer them at the soonest possible time smile.gif .

Mrs. Pepper
Sakura1287
Okay... forgive me if this is written somewhere else already, but here are my questions.

How long is this contest going to last, and how are the poems going to be judged?

Thanks!

-Sakura
ricelius
QUOTE (Sakura)
Okay... forgive me if this is written somewhere else already, but here are my questions.

How long is this contest going to last, and how are the poems going to be judged?

Thanks!

-Sakura


Actually I think we forgot to address the first point, so it's quite all right tongue.gif We decided to make the deadline for submissions Jan 4. After that, an independent jury will sort through all the submissions and come up with five nominations in each category. We'll then have a poll where all PK'ers have a chance to vote for each category, and the winner will be the poem with the most votes.

Ricelius
obsessedharryfan
forgive me if this has been asked already, but when are the winners going to be announced? unsure.gif

cool.gif HB cool.gif
Sakura1287
Thanks, Ricelius, that's a good way to do it.

-Sakura
ricelius
No problem, Sakura smile.gif

We'll announce the winners once the poll has been open for a month or so. There's no specific date yet as we're not sure how long the jury will need to come up with the nominations.

Ricelius
Sakura1287
The nominations.. those will be chosen by the Jury? And then those will be voted on by PKers? Right?

Just making sure I have it all down. lol

-Sakura
ricelius
Yup, that's right. Sort of like the Academy Awards etc.

Ricelius
obsessedharryfan
oh kool.. a great way to do it, Mrs. Pepper and ricelius! thumbup.gif
but im sure mine won't get chosen tongue.gif

cool.gif HB cool.gif
babyhalo19
hey! um I don't know if this has already been asked and I'm sorry if it has, but what are the prizes? tongue.gif I've just heard people saying they were really good, so I thought I'd ask. Oh, and can a person win more than one round? Not that I'm planning on this happening, but I'm just wondering. lol
obsessedharryfan
in the "Execrable" Catagory, is it supposed to be like writing about a ship, but it's supposed to be execrable? (i know im not making sense)
because i just finished one like that...

cool.gif HB cool.gif
ricelius
QUOTE (babyhalo19)
hey! um I don't know if this has already been asked and I'm sorry if it has, but what are the prizes?  I've just heard people saying they were really good, so I thought I'd ask. Oh, and can a person win more than one round? Not that I'm planning on this happening, but I'm just wondering. lol


Actually, there aren't any tangible prizes as of yet, beside the fame and glory of course. And what could be more rewarding than that? tongue.gif

QUOTE (obsessedharryfan)
in the "Execrable" Catagory, is it supposed to be like writing about a ship, but it's supposed to be execrable? (i know im not making sense)
because i just finished one like that...


Execrable can be anything remotely HP-related. Writing about a ship is fine, but it doesn't have to be. The only limitation is that, if you go with PK-breaking ships, they have to be somewhat ridiculed, if that makes sense. But then, anything execrable is ridiculing. biggrin.gif

Ricelius
obsessedharryfan
oh, thanx, ricelius!
i was a bit confused with it, but now i completely understand!!! biggrin.gif
i don't think my poems fitting in the execrable category, i mean, it's not evil, vicious or violent, but just plain weird, weird enough to cause ridicule tongue.gif

cool.gif HB cool.gif
ricelius
They don't have to be evil or anything, they just have to be bad. That is to say, the style needs to bad, your writing needs to suck, but in a funny way.
For examples, go to http://www.mcgonagall-online.org.uk/articles/profile.htm.

Ricelius
babyhalo19
so there won't be any prizes at all?
ricelius
Nope. What did you have in mind? PK isn't a profit-generating corporation, quite the contrary actually. Someone would have to pay for the prizes, if they were to be tangible, and I for one would rather contribute my money to the running of PK (hosting etc.) than prizes in a contest, were I to contribute at all. The contests at PK really are for amusement and entertainment only, done for the members by the members. But of course, if anyone is willing to donate prizes, they're very welcome smile.gif
gal-texter
I quite agree with ricelius's earlier post. One should not seek tangible returns from these contests. It should be honor enough to have one's poem make it to the final round.

Besides, these contests are another means by which Portkeymates could bond with one another. People get to polish their creative talents here. smile.gif

Perhaps you have non-tangible prizes in mind? I'm not coordinating this contest, but as a Portkeymate, I'd be interested.
Sakura1287
QUOTE
Perhaps you have non-tangible prizes in mind?


Maybe like a banner to put in their signatures? Or some sort of indicator for them to show off for winning?

Something like that would be interesting. smile.gif


XTina
obsessedharryfan
QUOTE (XTina)
Maybe like a banner to put in their signatures? Or some sort of indicator for them to show off for winning?

Something like that would be interesting.


yes, that would be kool... *wonders*
i saw earlier in the profiles that there was a "Awards" section... what's that for? (dumb question)

cool.gif HB cool.gif
ricelius
QUOTE
Maybe like a banner to put in their signatures? Or some sort of indicator for them to show off for winning?


I suppose that could be done... smile.gif And winners definitely have the right to put "Official PK Award-winning Poet" in their sigs biggrin.gif

QUOTE
i saw earlier in the profiles that there was a "Awards" section... what's that for? (dumb question)


huh.gif I'm not following you... Which profiles? Can you give a link? (Sorry, even dumber question tongue.gif)


EDIT: Hmmm... The quote tags seem not to be working... Or is it just me?
one quote tag was misspelled. ~gal-texter
Ah, thanks smile.gif
gal-texter
That "Awards" field in every member's Profile? It's Nappa's idea. Not related to the contests. I'm not sure it's fully operational, so let's wait for him to make the announcement himself.
obsessedharryfan
QUOTE (Pen)
That "Awards" field in every member's Profile?


yes, i think so... unsure.gif
anyway, i think this is getting off-topic, so ill end my question here smile.gif

cool.gif HB cool.gif
babyhalo19
okay, i sounded like a real jerk earlier, and i apologize...what i meant by prizes were what ppl said, signatures and avatars displaying that they won. those would be really cool, and i could volunteer to make a few of them, i've gotten quite good, just email me if you want me to! thanks,
Erin
Sakura1287
My newest idea was spung from those "contributor" pictures on the side of people's posts that show they donated money to PK...

Maybe you could even make something like that for the winners, like a step up from just a declaration in their signatures. It would be kind of impressive, since winning a contest is sort of a big deal.

XTina
obsessedharryfan
QUOTE (XTina)
Maybe you could even make something like that for the winners, like a step up from just a declaration in their signatures. It would be kind of impressive, since winning a contest is sort of a big deal.


Oh YEAH!!! thumbup.gif That would be really good!!! thumbup.gif
Can we do that, please?!?! sad.gif

cool.gif HB cool.gif

Edit: or we could have it like the awards on my thingie on the left over there *points to the thing under "Location"*
ricelius
So THAT is what those Awards are for... biggrin.gif I'll PM Nappa and see what he says. Really good ideas, everyone.

Ricelius
NAPPA
Hi guys. Yes, the award system is something I'm trying to design and code into the forum. ^.^ Kind of messy as you see at the moment. What will happen is that in your profile, Awards would show up. Also - if you click on obsessedharryfan's Award link, you see what is there at the moment. I will basically need to edit and make it presentable. People can see what kinds of prizes they have won. Portkey can't give away tangible gifts, but a little recognition if you post in the forums , should be decent enough of a compensation. ^.^

NAPPA
Sakura1287
QUOTE
Portkey can't give away tangible gifts, but a little recognition if you post in the forums , should be decent enough of a compensation.


I think it's perfect compensation. Especially for those of us who post alot, and want to show off our accomplishments a little bit. tongue.gif

XTina
gal-texter
Hm, I'm not keen on awards for merely posting a lot. You're actually making it hard for other people to catch up on the topics. And many of you are giving us Mods lots of work. wink.gif But I'm keen on awards for helping us do that work. And for making PK even more fun.

babyhalo - glad that we've cleared things up. Who knows, people might take you up on your offer. smile.gif
Sakura1287
QUOTE
   Hm, I'm not keen on awards for merely posting a lot.


blush.gif That's not what I meant.

I meant it would be nice for people who spend a lot of time at PK to be recognized if they do do more than just post. Such as members who set up different sorts of threads and smaller communities within PK. Not to boast but to give examples- the Latin Club and Peter Pan community/thread.

And by accomplishments, I didn't mean high post counts. I meant winning contests such as the Poetry and Reader's Choice.

Sorry if that came across wrong, and I know a few of us are a bit annoying.

But if it's any consolation, I keep my extensive nonsense/conversational posting to the Off Topic forum. In the other ones I stick to what's being discussed.

XTina
Facade
The prizes sound like a neat idea. And I agree they should not be given out so willingly but for some special occasions such as winning one of the two contests we have now.

However what happened to the award field? It kind of disappeared...
gal-texter
QUOTE
what happened to the award field? It kind of disappeared...

As I've told HB somewhere in Wonky Thread 24 (also in the Index), I was testing that award feature. It was only temporary. I'm done with the testing, so I deleted said award.
Sakura1287
Question...

Wasn't the contest supposed to have ended by now?

Sorry if I'm being annoying... blush.gif

XTina
ricelius
True, but we're still assembling the jury so we thought we might as well keep it open until they're ready to judge. That should be any day now, so don't worry... wink.gif

Nah, you're not too annoying tongue.gif

Ricelius
Sakura1287
Haha thanks for reassuring me. smile.gif

I'm glad it'll still be open.. who knows, maybe I'll have time to submit something else. biggrin.gif

XTina
Hpfreak06
Um...I was kind of wondering when you were going to post the nominations, the anticipation is killing me.user posted image

Tootles

Hpfreak06user posted image
Nousia
I have a rather silly question to ask: for how long are the polls going to last, and when are the winners going to be announced? (All right, so it was two in one - sorry, Lally and ricelius!)
ricelius
We'll post the nominations as soon as possible. We're still working on getting everything set up. Sorry for the delay.

The polls will be open for a month, and the winners will be announced immediately after they're closed.

Ricelius
Nousia
Thanks for clarifying. And it's all right about the delay - we can understand why, what with so many submissions and such.
babyhalo19
i understand, i was just wondering how its coming along....... its gotta be hard to have to judge all of those
Harmony04
When are you going to pick the winners?
Hpfreak06
Yeah when are you
Panorama
I'm sure they have a lot to do, thus explaining the delay. But I'm a bit curious myself, how is it coming along?
gal-texter
We all should remember that this is the first contest of its kind in Portkey, and possibly in the HP fandom. I often see 2 of the judges posting in their Judging Area on early mornings. I have it on good authority that their panel has picked the final entries for each category. Polls should be up soon. smile.gif

I'm not a contest coordinator, though. Just another meddling omnipresent Mod.


*cough* You're so far from that, Pen. You're so far from that. wink.gif - Nitya/S.D.


Far from meddling, or from being omnipresent? biggrin.gif tongue.gif

Neither. Hehe . .

Btw, Mrs. Pepper & ricelius, - don't hesitate to contact us Mods (esp. Quis, me, & Nitya) for help with setting up the polls. We can:
=>Set up a thread for each category
=>move all poem posts from the Submissions thread to the Category thread
=>insert polls in each thread.

We can probably show you the Poll threads first, so you can look over them before they get displayed to the public. smile.gif

All right, so you're a mod. laugh.gif Granted, that part's true. As for being far from a contest coordinator - nope! I was saying you were far from being an omnipresent and meddling one. Take it any way you want, though tongue.gif
Nousia
Pen's got a good point. Any Global Mod/Admin, for that matter can do just that - attaching polls, moving posts to the Category threads, and setting up threads for each category.

Although I probably can't do them, seeing as I'm competing in the poetry contest. tongue.gif So that leaves Pen and Quis.

- Nitya *cackles* See my note in your post, Pen. user posted image


So I'm neither far from meddling nor omnipresent. But I am a Mod. Does this mean you're saying that I'm far from being a contest coordinator? tongue.gif That is absolutely correct.

laugh.gif
ladylestrange
OK, I'm new to Portkey so please forgive if this is in the wrong spot. Please tell me where to put it for the Salazar/Helga ship.

Thanks
Lady Lestrange

Of Love and Loyalty
By ladylestrange

Inspiration within dreamed a school for tomorrow.

Ambition without brought the noble plan to sorrow.

The other founders quarrel; I’m not the enemy

So, they ask, if you would give it up, for love of me

I tell them, They cannot truly know you like I do

Yet Salazar, I wonder, did I ever know you?

I’ve stirred this potion daily and I think I know the key

But Love, I won’t pay the cost of what should never be.

I fear that I will strangle, like in a demon’s grip

More than that, My Love, I fear, you’ll change with each foul sip.

I’ve poured it in the garden ‘neath the tiny Angel’s Snare

Do you see the Devil vines and thorns now growing there?

Angered you have cast me off--though I’ll love you till I die.

Devotion never counts the cost, though jeering others wonder why.

Though wand is raised against me, I see loving in your eyes

I would rather die than hurt you. though others say that I’m unwise.

Not for power, nor fame, nor fortune, will I do what brings you pain

Even if you take your love and never speak to me again.

My love, I’ll give to you my heart. I’ll give to you my soul.

But do not ask my precious to help you toward this goal.

Now, everyday I worry, and tightness fills my chest.

Should I reveal our secrets? Should I betray the rest?

I ask the gilded serpents that grace your chamber door.

But your creatures do not know, what loyalty is for

They cannot see beyond ambition’s cunning eye.

They cannot love my love, nor do they even try.

I cannot even bleed for you. You throw it in the pit.

Nor can I renounce you and brave a path that’s split.

I dreamed again of heartache--my visions filled with pain.

I dreamed you lived forever: Lonely, tortured and insane.

So blind, Slytherin, I’ve taken emerald from the stone.

A house divided lives whose loyalty is shown.

When a child of Slytherin, looks here to friendship find.

Until that day, my Love, Slytherin, will labor blind.

Time moves on till Slytherins paint and dance and sing

When love is in the heart, on your finger is the ring

Tis not a curse I give thee, though you may think it so

I give you all my love. Consider me not your foe.

When at last you read this, my body lies cold and dead

Say Helga’s love is timeless. Not Helga’s love is dread.

Nousia
Ah, sorry to tell you this, but the poetry contest ended (exactly) a week ago. And the winners have already been announced. And there isn't a Salazar/Helga category - only the following four: Harry/Hermione, Ron/Luna, Lily/James and Draco/Ginny. This could be fitted in the General HP category, if there's any need to be.

However, there's going to be another contest next year. You can enter that when the time comes. Nice poem, by the way.
Excalibur
BAH! I'm an idiot. I was the one with the wrong forum ... meh. Congrats to the winners of the poetry awards wink.gif
ricelius
Excalibur, try posting this in the Administration forum instead; this thread is for the Poetry Contest only. But those are some good suggestions, I second most of them! smile.gif

Ricelius

[EDIT]
LOL! Look at the time stamp... Oh well...
[/EDIT]
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2009 Invision Power Services, Inc.