Got these old images from archive.org. Each was displayed on top of PK's webpages in time for the following contests:
-----------
Poetry Contest - 2003 Dec until 2004 Mar
Click to view attachment
archive.org's Dec 15 2003 capture of Portkey's board index
-----------
Readers Choice 1st round 2003 May to Sep
Click to view attachment <-- click to see bigger pic
archive.org's May 30 2003 capture of Portkey's fanfic page
-----------
Readers Choice 2nd round 2003 Nov until 2004 Mar
Click to view attachment
archive.org's Dec 15 2003 capture of Portkey's board index
-----------
Readers Choice 3nd round 2004 May to Aug
Look at the screencap down this post
-----------
Readers Choice 4th round 2004 Dec until 2005 Feb
archive.org's Jan 28 2005 capture of Portkey's board index
.